Six dated changes in dementia care, from blood tests to Medicare programs, and what each means for planning. Observed change is kept apart from forecast.
Continue reading...By: Jessica Cannon
The difference is timing and who has to say so: an immediately effective power of attorney gives the agent authority the day it is signed, while a springing one waits for a trigger, most often a finding that the person has become incapacitated, and with dementia that trigger can become the step where everything stalls. If your parent signed a durable power of attorney years ago, the family may not know which kind it is, and the answer decides whether the agent can pay a memory care bill this week or has to find a physician’s letter first.
Jessica Lizel Cannon frames the stakes as a window. As the founder of The Proactive Caregiver, a dementia caregiving strategist and Certified Dementia Practitioner, and a CPA with 28 years of financial experience, she works from a guideline that after a cognitive diagnosis, families typically have about one year to get powers of attorney, advance directives and banking forms signed while legal capacity still exists, and she warns that missing it can mean guardianship, locked assets and full retail care. That is her guideline from working with families, and it is not a legal deadline, because capacity is assessed one person at a time. Texas is the worked example below, and the rules differ by state.
Estimated reading time: 10 min read
A springing power of attorney starts when a named event occurs, usually a determination of incapacity, and an immediate one starts at signing. Both can be durable. Dementia matters because the person must have legal capacity to sign either one, and because a springing trigger can depend on an evaluation the person may not think is needed. An elder law attorney explains how a specific document handles all of this.
A power of attorney lets one person, the agent, act for another, the principal. Under the Uniform Power of Attorney Act, the model law many states have adopted, a power of attorney is effective when it is executed unless the principal provides that it becomes effective at a future date or on a future event or contingency. The first kind is called immediately effective. The second is the springing, or contingent, kind.
Texas works from the same idea. Estates Code section 751.0021 treats a power of attorney as durable when the instrument says, in plain terms, that the power is not affected by the principal’s later disability or incapacity, or that it becomes effective on the principal’s disability or incapacity, or when it says so in other wording that is equally clear. The first describes an immediately effective power. The second is the springing form, in which the authority begins only when the incapacity does.
The Texas statutory form makes immediate effect its starting point. Its effective-date language says that, unless the principal directs otherwise, the power of attorney is effective immediately and continues until it terminates, and it then offers the two alternatives: one that the power is not affected by the principal’s later disability or incapacity, and one that it becomes effective upon the principal’s disability or incapacity. A family reading an existing Texas document can look for which alternative was marked and whether the document defines incapacity itself. That reading, and what follows from it, is work for an attorney licensed in the state where the document will be used.
The table follows the uniform act and the Texas statutory form.
| Question | Immediately effective | Springing |
|---|---|---|
| When does the agent’s authority begin? | When the document is signed, unless it says otherwise | When the trigger named in the document occurs, most often the principal’s incapacity |
| Who says the trigger has happened? | No one; there is no trigger | The person the document names. If it names no one, the uniform act points to a written determination by a physician (or licensed psychologist where adopted), an attorney, a judge or an appropriate official |
| What can the agent do before then? | Act under the document, while the principal keeps the right to make their own decisions | Nothing under the document until the trigger is met |
| What can slow it down? | Everything depends on trusting the agent from the first day | The determination itself: an evaluation, a written certification and the time they take |
| Does it survive later incapacity? | Yes, when it is durable | Yes; its authority begins with the incapacity |
The uniform act lets the principal name one or more people to determine in writing that the triggering event has happened. If the trigger is incapacity and no one is named, or the named person is unable or unwilling to act, the power of attorney takes effect on a written determination by a physician, an attorney, a judge or an appropriate governmental official, depending on how incapacity is defined.
The Texas statutory form supplies its own default for the springing version. When a definition of disability or incapacity is not written into the document, the principal is considered incapacitated if a physician certifies in writing, at a date later than the signing and based on a medical examination, that the principal is mentally incapable of managing financial affairs. Each of those steps comes at a moment when a family may already be short on time, and each one has to be written down.
Two things shift when dementia is in the picture. The first is the signing itself. The Alzheimer’s Association says a person with dementia keeps the right to make their own decisions as long as they have legal capacity, and that the agent’s authority starts once the person can no longer decide. Jessica puts the consequence bluntly on her Financial Wellness page: “If your loved one already has significant cognitive decline, it may be too late to execute these documents legally.” Whether a particular person has the capacity to sign on a particular day is a question for an attorney, and our article on whether a parent with dementia can still sign legal documents explains how families usually meet it.
The second is the trigger. A springing power of attorney that depends on an evaluation meets a hard fact about some forms of dementia. Jessica describes anosognosia as “a neurological condition where the brain cannot perceive its own impairment,” and lists among its signs that “Your loved one refuses help because they don’t think they need it.” It is a practical observation, not a legal one, that a parent who does not believe anything has changed may not agree to the evaluation a springing document requires. An attorney can explain how a given document handles that situation.
The Uniform Law Commission’s comment to its effective-date section records the argument openly. It calls the default rule a best-practices view: any agent who can be trusted to act under a springing power of attorney should be trustworthy enough to hold an immediate one. It also reports that principals often prefer springing powers, most likely to keep their privacy in the hope that no one will ever need to act for them.
The comment cites a 2002 national survey of lawyers by Linda Whitton: 61 percent of respondents said their clients preferred immediate powers, 23 percent said springing powers, and 16 percent saw no trend, while 89 percent said a power of attorney statute should authorize springing powers. Those numbers describe what lawyers reported twenty-four years ago, not what any family should choose. They show that the trade-off between privacy and speed is a real one that thoughtful people resolve in different ways.
Reading an existing document is different from drafting a new one, and a licensed attorney in your parent’s state is the person to do either. These are the questions families commonly bring, framed so that the answers come from the document and the law rather than from guesses:
A financial power of attorney is one of five documents on Jessica’s Financial Wellness page, alongside a medical power of attorney, a HIPAA authorization, a living will and a last will. They do different jobs. The uniform act’s comment says its effective-date section does not give an agent the power to make health care decisions, which a medical power of attorney covers, and Jessica’s page notes that even with a medical power of attorney, providers can refuse to share information without an explicit HIPAA authorization.
The act does address one overlap. A person the principal authorizes to determine incapacity may act as the principal’s personal representative under HIPAA to get access to health information and talk with the health care provider, because that person usually needs it to make the determination. A springing clause is a financial document that also depends on access to medical information, which is one more reason it tends to need an attorney’s reading.
The Proactive Caregiver Method page describes Jessica’s role as connecting what families usually hold in separate hands. The elder law attorney has the documents, a doctor has the diagnosis, and she reads “the diagnosis, the money, the legal window and the family together.” For a parent who has already signed a durable power of attorney, her four readings turn into four questions held side by side: when the diagnosis came and how far it has progressed, what the document says about when it starts, who the named agent is and whether the family agrees on that choice, and what care costs are coming that an agent would have to pay.
That is what Jessica evaluates, and where Jessica hands off is just as specific. Which form a family holds, whether a particular document works and whether a parent still has the capacity to sign are an attorney’s questions, so Jessica sends them to a licensed elder law attorney in the parent’s state. Her contribution is to place the diagnosis date and the status of each document on one timeline, so the attorney’s work begins early enough to matter and the family arrives knowing what to ask.
Her coaching page names the Crisis stage as the moment when “a diagnosis, fall, hospitalization, safety concern, financial issue, or change in care needs may have shifted everything quickly,” and lists accountability among what coaching adds: keeping moving “instead of waiting until the next crisis forces a decision.” Jessica works with families nationwide through virtual coaching, with in-person roots in Austin and Central Texas.
Jessica Cannon is a CPA with 28 years of financial experience and a Certified Dementia Practitioner. What she does is help families with the financial side of dementia care: reading a Medicare denial letter, a memory care contract and a dementia timeline together, so the money makes sense before decisions get made. If you would like help applying any of this to your own situation, you can book a discovery call.
15 minutes, to work out whether this is something she can help with.
Q: What is the difference between a springing and an immediately effective power of attorney?
A: An immediately effective power of attorney gives the agent authority when it is signed, unless the document sets a later date. A springing power of attorney gives the agent authority only when a named event occurs, most often the principal’s incapacity. Both can be durable, meaning they continue after the principal becomes incapacitated, and both end at the principal’s death.
Q: Who decides when a springing power of attorney takes effect?
A: The document controls. The Uniform Power of Attorney Act lets the principal name people to determine in writing that the trigger has occurred, and when none is named it points to a written determination by a physician, an attorney, a judge or an appropriate official. Texas’s statutory form supplies a default of a physician’s written certification when the document contains no definition of incapacity.
Q: Can someone with dementia still sign a power of attorney?
A: It depends on legal capacity at the time of signing, which an attorney assesses for the particular person. The Alzheimer’s Association says a person with dementia keeps the right to make their own decisions while they have legal capacity. Jessica’s Financial Wellness page warns that it may be too late once cognitive decline is significant, which is why the timing question comes up early.
Q: What if my parent has dementia and no power of attorney at all?
A: An elder law attorney in your parent’s state can explain the options, which may include a court guardianship process. Jessica describes the cost of missing the window as guardianship, locked assets and full retail care. Our comparison of guardianship and power of attorney for a parent with dementia lays out how the two differ.
About this article. Jessica Cannon is a CPA with 28 years of financial experience and a Certified Dementia Practitioner. She provides financial coaching, not legal or medical services. This article is general information about how these systems work, not advice about your situation, and it is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. It is not medical advice, and it is not individualized tax or financial advice.
For the legal instruments themselves, including wills, powers of attorney and guardianship, you will need a licensed attorney in your own state. Medicaid and long-term care rules also differ by state and change over time, so any Texas detail here is an example rather than a rule that will apply to you.