Five Voices That Say You Are Failing as a Caregiver, and What to Do With Them

By: Jessica Cannon

Five Voices That Say You Are Failing as a Caregiver, and What to Do With Them

The five voices say that you should be able to handle this, that resentment means you do not love them, that wanting a break is selfish, that other people have it worse, and that you will regret not doing more, and each one can be named, traced to where it came from and answered with evidence. To see where they tend to arrive, picture a hypothetical caregiver, not a real family, standing at the sink after a week of broken sleep while a friend offers to sit with her mother for the afternoon. The offer is on the table, and whether she takes it is the decision in front of her. If a particular sentence turns up at that moment telling her that she is failing, it is likely to be one of the five below.

Jessica Lizel Cannon cared for her own mother through frontotemporal dementia and four misdiagnoses, and on her Self-Care page she describes losing her health, her marriage and her identity along the way. She is the founder of The Proactive Caregiver, a dementia caregiving strategist, a Certified Dementia Practitioner and a CPA with 28 years of financial experience. She asks caregivers about the voice that says “you’re not doing enough,” and she has a name for it: the “itty bitty shitty committee.” Every caregiver, she says, has one.

Estimated reading time: 9 min read

Key Insights

Jessica Cannon’s committee has five common members: a standard you cannot meet, a ban on resentment, a verdict on rest, a comparison with people who have it worse, and a forecast of regret. Research on caregiver guilt documents several of these themes. Her four moves, name it, externalize it, question the source and replace it with evidence, apply to each, and she stresses that the goal is a different seat for the committee rather than silence.

Table of Contents

1. “You Should Be Able to Handle This”

Jessica’s first example sets you against the women who came before you: “You should be able to handle this. Your grandmother took care of five kids and her parents.” She says these voices are inherited scripts that come from your family, your culture and your own unprocessed guilt, and that they served a purpose once, probably keeping you safe from criticism.

A qualitative study of 13 family caregivers of people with dementia, published in Clinical Gerontologist in 2022, sorted caregiver guilt into seven categories, and guilt that comes from one’s own limitations was one of them. The useful move here is the one Jessica calls questioning the source: “Whose voice is that actually? Your mother’s? Society’s? Your fear?” A standard handed down by a grandmother’s era was never measured against the hours, forms and decisions you are carrying now.

2. “If You Really Loved Them, You Wouldn’t Feel Resentful”

The second voice treats a feeling as evidence against your love. The same 2022 study lists guilt for feeling negative emotions as its own category, which means the voice is common enough that researchers had to give it a name. Jessica’s Self-Care page describes where the unspoken version goes: “You don’t have time to feel sad, angry, or scared,” she writes, “so you don’t,” until it comes out sideways as resentment, rage or numbness.

Her answer is the first of her four moves, which is to name it. Say, even to yourself, that this is the committee talking. Her Advocacy page puts the principle in a list of the caregiver’s rights, among them the right to experience negative feelings. A feeling is information about the load you are carrying, and it can sit alongside love without canceling it.

3. “You’re Being Selfish for Wanting a Break”

The third voice rules on rest. The Alzheimer’s Association describes respite care as giving caregivers a temporary rest from caregiving while the person with dementia remains in a safe setting, and suggests using the time for errands, appointments or time with friends. Its caregiver-stress page also lists exhaustion, sleeplessness and withdrawal from friends among the signs that a caregiver is carrying too much.

Jessica’s second move is to externalize: “These aren’t your thoughts. They’re old recordings.” A recording can be heard without being obeyed. For the caregiver at the sink, that might mean letting the voice finish its sentence and saying yes to the friend’s afternoon anyway, because the decision belongs to her and not to the committee.

4. “Other People Have It Worse. You Have No Right to Complain”

The fourth voice uses comparison to close off help before you ask for it. The Alzheimer’s Association’s answer, on its caregiver-stress page, is plain: “No situation is too big or too small” to call its 24/7 Helpline at 800.272.3900, which connects callers with local resources, crisis assistance and emotional support.

This is where Jessica’s third move, replacing the voice with evidence, does its work. Her question is: “What would someone who actually knows your situation say?” A friend who had watched your last three months would not rank your difficulty against a stranger’s. They would more likely tell you what they had seen.

5. “You’re Going to Look Back and Regret Not Doing More”

The fifth voice speaks in the future tense, and it is often joined to grief. A systematic review of 31 publications on grief in dementia caregivers, published in the International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry in 2013, found that anticipatory grief involves multiple losses for the caregiver and for the person with dementia, and that anticipation, ambiguity about the future, anger, frustration and guilt are core features. The review rated the evidence on how common it is as poor quality, with studies reporting anticipatory grief in 47 percent to 71 percent of caregivers.

A preliminary analysis of 87 caregivers in a residential care transition trial found guilt about not meeting self-set expectations, such as visiting often enough, among the common themes after a relative moved into long-term care, and adult children reported guilt more often than spouses, at 37.5 percent against 26.7 percent. Jessica’s closing line suits a voice like this: “You don’t have to eliminate the committee. You just have to stop letting them run the meeting.”

Why the committee sounds the way it does

Jessica’s Self-Care page connects the committee to what she calls the hereditary mindset trap, in which caregiving revives old roles. Her examples are specific: the child who was never good enough becomes the caregiver who can never do enough, the peacekeeper becomes the caregiver who absorbs everyone’s emotions, the invisible child becomes the caregiver who martyrs herself without asking for help, and the responsible one becomes the caregiver who cannot delegate or trust anyone else.

Read against the five voices, those patterns help with the second move. A voice that insists you should be able to handle everything may be the responsible child still on duty. A voice that rules out a break may belong to the invisible child. Both teachings sit in the Self-Care pillar of The Proactive Caregiver Method, the five-pillar approach Jessica built from her own years as a caregiver, and the Method treats the caregiver’s own health as one of the connected areas that the others depend on. Sorting the voices does not require certainty about your own family. It only needs a question, whose voice is this, and honest attention to the answer.

How to use the four moves in practice

Jessica’s four moves are short enough to carry. Name the voice, and say that it is the committee talking. Externalize it by treating it as an old recording. Question the source by asking whose voice it really is. Replace it with evidence by asking what someone who knows your situation would say. She does not promise that the voices stop, and her teaching is that they do not have to. Back at the sink, the hypothetical caregiver would not need to win an argument. If she named the voice, asked whose it was and listed what she had actually done that week, her friend’s offer would look like what someone who knew her situation would likely call it: an afternoon of help worth accepting.

  • Name it when the sentence arrives, using her words if they help.
  • Externalize it by remembering that it is a recording and not a conclusion.
  • Question the source by asking whose voice it is: your mother’s, society’s or your fear’s.
  • Replace it with evidence by naming what you have actually done this week and what help is available.

Where coaching and a counselor each fit

Jessica’s Self-Care page is direct about her lane: “I don’t do support groups. I don’t do sympathy. I do strategy.” On her coaching page, one of the quarters in her framework is Emotional Resilience and Grief, described as helping a caregiver “recognize what you’re carrying, process changing emotions, and develop tools for navigating grief and uncertainty.” That is the work of turning the committee’s verdicts into questions about what you need and which supports exist.

Her page is equally direct about where coaching stops: “A licensed therapist or counselor is the right call for depression, anxiety, or grief that will not lift.” Jessica works with families nationwide through virtual coaching, with in-person roots in Austin and Central Texas, and when a caregiver brings her this question she reads the voices, the care situation and the supports available as one picture. Our article on how to stay yourself when everyone needs you takes the identity side of this further.

Protect Your Family’s Financial Future

Jessica Cannon is a CPA with 28 years of financial experience and a Certified Dementia Practitioner. What she does is help families with the financial side of dementia care: reading a Medicare denial letter, a memory care contract and a dementia timeline together, so the money makes sense before decisions get made. If you would like help applying any of this to your own situation, you can book a discovery call.

15 minutes, to work out whether this is something she can help with.

Book a discovery call

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why do I feel guilty as a caregiver even when I am doing everything I can?

A: Guilt is a documented part of family caregiving. A 2022 qualitative study of 13 family caregivers of people with dementia found seven kinds, including guilt from one’s limitations, guilt for feeling negative emotions and guilt for neglecting other areas of life. Jessica Cannon teaches that the voices behind it are often inherited scripts, and that questioning where each came from is the first step.

Q: Is it normal to feel resentful toward the person I care for?

A: A systematic review of grief in dementia caregivers found that anger, frustration and guilt are core features of the experience. Jessica’s Advocacy page lists the right to experience negative feelings among a caregiver’s rights. Resentment that does not ease, or that comes with depression or anxiety, is worth bringing to a licensed counselor or your own doctor.

Q: How do I stop the voice that says I am failing?

A: Jessica does not promise to remove it. Her moves are to name it, externalize it, question its source and replace it with evidence, and her closing line is that you do not have to eliminate the committee, only stop letting it run the meeting.

Q: When is caregiver guilt a reason to get professional help?

A: The Alzheimer’s Association lists exhaustion, sleeplessness and withdrawal from friends among the signs of caregiver stress and recommends talking with your doctor if you notice them regularly. Depression, anxiety or grief that will not lift belongs with a licensed therapist or counselor, as her own page says.

Citations

  • “I Feel Guilty”: Exploring Guilt-Related Dynamics in Family Caregivers of People with Dementia (Gallego-Alberto and colleagues, Clinical Gerontologist, 2022). A qualitative analysis of 13 family caregivers identified seven categories of guilt, including guilt from one’s limitations and guilt for feeling negative emotions. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32496935/
  • Grief reactions in dementia caregivers: a systematic review (Chan and colleagues, International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 2013). Reviews 31 publications and finds that anticipatory grief, with guilt, anger and frustration as core features, is common, while the evidence on prevalence is of poor quality. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22407743/
  • Identifying Predictors of Guilt Following Placement of Family Member with Dementia into Residential Long-Term Care (Statz and colleagues, Innovation in Aging, 2019). A preliminary analysis of 87 caregivers reporting guilt more often among adult children than spouses and describing common guilt themes after placement. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6840489/
  • Caregiver stress (Alzheimer’s Association). Lists signs of caregiver stress, describes respite care and the 24/7 Helpline, and advises talking with a doctor if signs persist. https://www.alz.org/help-support/caregiving/caregiver-health/caregiver-stress

About this article. Jessica Cannon is a CPA with 28 years of financial experience and a Certified Dementia Practitioner. She provides financial coaching, not legal or medical services. This article is general information about how these systems work, not advice about your situation, and it is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. It is not medical advice, and it is not individualized tax or financial advice.

For the legal instruments themselves, including wills, powers of attorney and guardianship, you will need a licensed attorney in your own state. Medicaid and long-term care rules also differ by state and change over time, so any Texas detail here is an example rather than a rule that will apply to you.


About the Author

A former corporate accountant turned caregiver advocate, Jessica Lizel Cannon is the founder of Proactive Caregiver. She combines her financial background with her experience as a Certified Dementia Practitioner to empower families navigating the "emotional storm" of caregiving. Through her book, podcast, and consulting, Jessica helps caregivers find balance, guilt-free living, and spiritual strength.