Is It Okay to Lie to a Parent With Dementia?

By: Jessica Cannon

Is It Okay to Lie to a Parent With Dementia?

Sometimes, but far less often than most families fear, because many moments that seem to call for a lie are better met by answering the feeling behind a parent’s question. Picture, as a hypothetical, a daughter standing in her mother’s kitchen at suppertime while her mother asks, for the third time this hour, when her husband will be home from work, a husband who died four years ago. The plain truth tells her mother about the death as if it were brand new news, and a made-up reason that he is running late is simply untrue. A family standing in that gap can feel that every available answer costs something, and that discomfort belongs to people who care about honesty, which makes it worth a straight answer.

Jessica Lizel Cannon comes to this question as a Certified Dementia Practitioner and a dementia caregiving strategist, and as the founder of The Proactive Caregiver she pairs that training with 28 years of financial experience as a CPA. Her Dementia Care Navigation page says what understanding the disease changes for a family: it is “the difference between constant conflict and genuine connection.”

Estimated reading time: 10 min read

Key Insights

Lying to a parent with dementia is a real ethical question, and the guidance families lean on starts well before any lie: let harmless mistakes pass, listen for the feeling behind the words, and offer a gentle redirection. Jessica’s Dementia Care Navigation page reserves therapeutic fibbing for moments when it is necessary for safety, and a published taxonomy of lies in dementia care separates lies told for the person’s benefit from lies told for the caregiver’s convenience. Sudden new confusion or agitation belongs with the parent’s doctor first. When siblings share the work, agreeing on one consistent answer keeps the parent from hearing several.

Table of Contents

Is it ever okay to lie to a parent with dementia?

The honest answer depends on timing and stakes, and Jessica’s own page treats it that way. Among the steps she lists for a family that has come to understand anosognosia is to “Start using therapeutic fibbing when necessary for safety.” The two conditions inside that sentence carry the weight: the fib has to be necessary, and it has to be about safety.

Care researchers have looked at why lies turn up in dementia care at all. A 2019 paper in OBM Geriatrics by Rachel Mills and colleagues built a taxonomy of them and found that the lies were mainly used in the best interests of people with dementia, often to reduce distress or manage difficult behavior. A smaller group, which the authors call fobbing off, appeared to serve the caregiver’s convenience rather than the person’s needs. They conclude that using a lie appropriately takes a good understanding of the person’s perspective and life experience.

That research describes what caregivers do and why. It cannot tell any single family what to do, and a parent’s doctor and care team are the right people to ask about the hard cases.

Why does correcting a parent with dementia so often go badly?

Jessica’s page describes anosognosia as a neurological condition in which the brain cannot perceive its own impairment, which is why a parent who insists nothing is wrong may sincerely believe it. Her list of things to stop includes asking “Don’t you remember?” and arguing about what a parent can and cannot do. Our article on anosognosia and family decisions explains why a parent’s disagreement is not simply willful denial. Her page also describes the emotional shift for the family: behavior that felt like defiance starts to read as a symptom, and the frustration softens into compassion.

This part of her page reflects both halves of Jessica’s background. As a Certified Dementia Practitioner, Jessica teaches families what her page calls the detective mindset: instead of asking “Why are they being difficult?”, ask “What are they trying to communicate?” Jessica also cared for her own mother through frontotemporal dementia and four misdiagnoses, and that experience is where her page says she learned what understanding the disease changes for a family. It is the reason Jessica’s guidance begins with entering a parent’s reality rather than correcting it.

The Alzheimer’s Association gives the same advice in plain words. Its tips for the middle stage say “Avoid arguing. If the person says something you don’t agree with, let it be,” and “Avoid criticizing or correcting. Instead, listen and try to find the meaning in what the person says.”

The Alzheimer’s Society in the United Kingdom adds a question worth asking before any correction: “Think about whether it is necessary to correct these beliefs.” Its guidance says that when a belief is not causing harm or anxiety, you may not need to correct it at all.

What can you say first, before reaching for a fib?

Jessica’s page offers a communication framework she developed, called PACE: Pause, Adjust, Connect and Encourage. The step that fits this question best is Connect, which her page sums up as “Connect before you direct.”

  • Pause: take a breath before answering, because a parent can pick up on a caregiver’s stress even when the words are hard to follow.
  • Adjust: meet the parent where they are in this moment, since dementia fluctuates from hour to hour.
  • Connect: make eye contact, use their name and offer a touch on the hand if that is welcome, before asking anything of them.
  • Encourage: focus on what they can do, and offer limited choices, two options rather than five.

What does that sound like in the kitchen?

Jessica’s page includes an example that shows the pattern. Where a daughter might say “Dad, you already ate breakfast. Don’t you remember?”, the page suggests a pause and a breath, then “Are you feeling hungry? Let’s get you something,” with two choices of food. The answer meets the need under the question and never argues the fact.

In the hypothetical kitchen, the same logic points toward the feeling behind the question. The Alzheimer’s Association’s guidance for the later stages says to “Consider the feelings behind words or sounds. Sometimes the emotions being expressed are more important than what’s being said.” One response that fits that guidance is for the daughter to sit down beside her mother and ask about the husband her mother is missing. That answer has not told the death as news, and it has not invented a reason for him to be late.

When does a therapeutic fib fit?

Therapeutic fibbing is the phrase Jessica’s page uses for a gentle untruth told to protect a parent’s safety. Her page ties it to the moments when safety is at stake, and its own example of such a moment is a father who insists he can still drive and genuinely believes it. Whether and how a family responds in a situation like that is a conversation for the parent’s doctor and care team, who know the diagnosis and the person.

Families can borrow three questions from the research and the guidance above before they use any fib. They come from our own reading of those sources, and they are meant to slow a decision down, not to certify it.

  • Whose need does this serve? The taxonomy’s line between lies told for the person and lies told for the caregiver’s convenience is the one to watch.
  • Does a true, calm answer do the same work? The Alzheimer’s Society question about whether a correction is necessary belongs here.
  • Is the goal safety or relief from distress, and does everyone caring for the parent know the plan?

What if the behavior is new?

Not every distressing statement is a communication puzzle. Jessica’s page says that behavior in dementia always has a reason, and it lists physical discomfort, hunger, medication side effects, a loud or dim environment and fear among the possible causes. It also flags sudden behavioral changes, especially new confusion, agitation or hallucinations, as possible signs of a urinary tract infection, which it calls a medical matter that requires immediate attention. A change like that goes to the parent’s doctor before it becomes a family debate about what to say. Our guide to sundowning, the late-day pattern, and how to manage it covers the evening hours when many of these questions surface.

What if siblings disagree about what to say?

A parent who hears one answer from a daughter and another from a son has two versions to hold, and the siblings have an argument about honesty waiting to happen. Jessica’s Family Dynamics page names old family roles and different grief timelines among the reasons siblings fight. Settling the response to the repeated questions on a calm afternoon, before the evening they come up, takes some of the heat out of the moment, and it lets the person closest to the daily care stop carrying the decision alone.

Whatever a family decides, a fib holds up better when everyone who cares for the parent has heard the plan, including the sibling who visits on weekends and the home health aide who covers the afternoons. A story that one person tells and another contradicts has stopped protecting anyone.

How does coaching help a family settle this?

Jessica works with families nationwide through virtual coaching, with in-person roots in Austin and Central Texas. On her coaching page, the second quarter of the framework, Find The Words, aims to “Build stronger communication skills and learn to advocate more confidently for your loved one and yourself.” Its Dementia Care Navigation pillar covers changing behaviors and communication “so you can respond to the person” and not only to the diagnosis.

When a family brings this question to Jessica, she works from the rule that comes before any fib: connect before you direct. Her Method page describes her as someone who reads the diagnosis, the money, the legal window and the family together. For a question like this one that means the parent’s diagnosis and the siblings’ different views get read together, a fib stays reserved for moments of safety, and a sudden change in behavior goes to the doctor. And if coaching is the wrong tool for a family, her discovery-call page says she will tell them so: “If coaching isn’t right for you, I’ll tell you and point you somewhere better.”

Protect Your Family’s Financial Future

Jessica Cannon is a CPA with 28 years of financial experience and a Certified Dementia Practitioner. What she does is help families with the financial side of dementia care: reading a Medicare denial letter, a memory care contract and a dementia timeline together, so the money makes sense before decisions get made. If you would like help applying any of this to your own situation, you can book a discovery call.

15 minutes, to work out whether this is something she can help with.

Book a discovery call

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is it okay to lie to a parent with dementia?

A: Sometimes. Jessica Cannon’s Dementia Care Navigation page reserves therapeutic fibbing for moments when it is necessary for safety, and the Alzheimer’s Association’s guidance begins earlier: avoid arguing, let a disagreement pass, and listen for the meaning in what the person says. Research on lies in dementia care separates those told for the person’s benefit from those told for the caregiver’s convenience, and the parent’s doctor and care team can help with the hard cases.

Q: What is therapeutic fibbing?

A: Therapeutic fibbing is the phrase Jessica’s Dementia Care Navigation page uses for a gentle untruth told to protect a parent with dementia, and her page ties it to situations where it is necessary for safety. A 2019 taxonomy of lies in dementia care in OBM Geriatrics found that lies in this setting were mainly used in the best interests of the person, often to reduce distress.

Q: Should I correct a parent with dementia when they say something that is not true?

A: The Alzheimer’s Association’s middle-stage tips advise avoiding arguing and criticizing or correcting, and listening for the meaning in what the person says. The Alzheimer’s Society asks whether a correction is necessary at all and notes that a belief causing no harm or anxiety may not need one. A statement that touches the parent’s safety is a question for their doctor and care team.

Q: What if my siblings disagree about what to say to our parent?

A: Agree on a shared response to the repeated questions before the next evening they come up, so the parent does not hear several versions. Jessica’s Family Dynamics page names old roles and different grief timelines among the reasons siblings fight, and a discovery call with her is one place a family can talk through the disagreement with someone who works from that material.

Citations

About this article. Jessica Cannon is a CPA with 28 years of financial experience and a Certified Dementia Practitioner. She provides financial coaching, not legal or medical services. This article is general information about how these systems work, not advice about your situation, and it is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. It is not medical advice, and it is not individualized tax or financial advice.

For the legal instruments themselves, including wills, powers of attorney and guardianship, you will need a licensed attorney in your own state. Medicaid and long-term care rules also differ by state and change over time, so any Texas detail here is an example rather than a rule that will apply to you.


About the Author

A former corporate accountant turned caregiver advocate, Jessica Lizel Cannon is the founder of Proactive Caregiver. She combines her financial background with her experience as a Certified Dementia Practitioner to empower families navigating the "emotional storm" of caregiving. Through her book, podcast, and consulting, Jessica helps caregivers find balance, guilt-free living, and spiritual strength.